Most Reliable Trials Machine?

[uhoh7]

My buddy has about 3000 US to spend. I know used machines are always a gamble and there are lots of variables.

But which machines have proven most bulletproof and effective from 1994 on?

Thanks sirs

Edited December 1, 2005 by uhoh7

[scorpa3]

At one time I would have said the Beta's have the best build quality, but they do suffer badly from electrical failure (if you get a bad one like I did.)

A good rule to follow is; 'have a look at everything and buy by condition.'

A well looked after Gas Gas is a better buy than a thrashed and abused Scorpa, although the Scorpa has very good build quality when new.

[montman]

For 2 - Montesa 315 and Scorpa SY250 in my experience :hat:

[lewis_gasgas]

My Gas Gas 1998 Tx 250 was great nothing ever really went wrong on that unless i broke it and chain and sprocket. Good bike.

[charliechitlins]

You'll get a good answer in support of all the machines.

My prejudices from ownership and from being the local wrench-spinner, would lead me to put my 3000 into a Sherco. I guess that would get a good '02 or '03.

It's not my habit to trash other machines, and I have often said that they are all good. Most of the recurring problems with these bikes are small and easily sorted (not to say that some aren't pretty annoying!), but I have found Sherco to be the least idiosyncratic.

I think Montesa would be a close second.

Actually...my only real complaint with the Montesa is purely personal; I feel a lot of buzzing/vibration in the bars and pegs. No doubt due to the stiffness of the frame. I've never seen it discussed on this bulletin board, so I'm probably in a very small minority....again.

[jam]

GAS GAS ALLDAY LONG WITH THE WIND BEHIND YOU.

HAD 7 SINCE 93, NO PROBS.

[barcota]

Montesa 4RT !!!

[n.wales_sherco_lad1]

i would personally go for a montesa 315r as they are strongest machine also beta is very bulletproof. get one of these bikes and get the newest model for your money.

hope this helps !

[lewis_gasgas]

barcota if you can get a 4rt for 3000 dollars , you can get me one.

[atomant]

You'll get a good answer in support of all the machines.

My prejudices from ownership and from being the local wrench-spinner, would lead me to put my 3000 into a Sherco.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I agree 2T though I fell off mine loads of times and only ever bent the bars. Sturdy workhorse :santa1:

[cota kid]

Had 4 Montesa Cota 315's with no major problems. Great bike, extremely well put together.

[the artist formerly known as ish]

I have just what your mate needs, will take plenty of stick and keep going strong.

97 Beta techno used by an old lad in our club to come out and help clear sections and watch events, never trialed, excellent condition, the seat pad just is bolted to the regular stock fender bolts.

Runs like a clock $1800 will meet you at Pendleton if your interested.

[the artist formerly known as ish]

t'other side

[jjwhite]

for absolute reliability and all prejudice's aside. pretty much any of them, all of the bikes within the past 5 eyars have had their own little problems but all can be sorted easily, gas gas had gearbox problems, shorco had mains etc.etc.

but if looking at a sherco be wary of mains.

some beta's have electrical faults.

the mont 315 and scorpa are pretty much bullet proof, but the mont will give you problems (when picking it up and dragging it out of sections)

but seriously, most of the bikes are sound, get him to have a ride on a few and he can buy the one he likes the most.

[nitjay - hrc]

nearly ever beta ive known has begun to sound rough after a few years, i dont know what it is, a reasonable number have electrical problems. I just cant say anyone in my riding group would get one after many have had bad experiences with them.

Having said that if your lucky enough to get a good one and really look after it they can be excellent, a friend of mine had a 200 Beta that i loved becuase it was such smooth power delivery and it ticks along nicely.

Then again 02-03 gassers have been known to have niggly little problems go wrong, i.e Kickstarts snapping etc etc...